Okemo Fire Tower

Maple Sugar and American History

Until the early 1850s all maple sap was made into maple sugar.  If someone wanted syrup, boiling water was added to the crystallized sugar to make the desired consistency.  This was due in part to the problem that syrup that hasn’t been canned will mold and spoil quickly, but that’s getting ahead of the story.

In Colonial America, sugar was very political involving salves, rum, molasses and the Caribbean Islands.  Many New Englanders felt that cane sugar was tainted with immorality (even through they made fortunes from rum) because of the slavery that was a key part of cane sugar cultivation.  Benjamin Franklin even advocated to make maple sugar the “natural sweetener” in order to avoid a product so closely tied to slave labor.

Per capita consumption of maple sugar remained quite high at least in the northern states through the first half of the 19th century.  However, food science was beginning to become part of American life.  During the decade before the Civil War advances were being made in the canning of products.  Maple syrup may well have been the first to be successfully canned simply because it is easy to can or jar.  At the same time pickles and condensed milk and finally meats all became easy to preserve and safe to eat.  Many historians believe that the ability to can and preserve food was a key component in the success of the Union Army during the Civil War.

An interesting part of the early maple sugar tradition still lingers to this day.  If you are trying to compete with cane sugar in the marketplace you would desire to produce a white sugar with hardly any maple flavor.  This would be more on par with commercial sugar.  The darker more mapley flavored product would not be worth quite as much. 

This is the basis for the current grading system in which pale syrup with a light maple flavor (fancy) is still more expensive than a darker heavier flavored syrup (dark amber), even through most people want maple syrup to have a strong maple flavor.  If supply and demand was the only factor dictating price, the darker grades of syrup would probably surpass fancy grade in cost.

Contributed by Bruce McEnaney

Sign up here to receive our monthly newsletter and more articles like this one.